So we got the brown first to test! They fit true to size. Only come in whole sizes, so order whatever you closest whole size is. Hailey is 8 or 8.5 and the 8 fits fine. But if you were like usually an 8.5/9 I'd do the 9. We have sizes 5-10 in right now! Coolest thing? You can just wipe these off when they get dirty!! 🤎